Welcome back beautiful Mad River Glen or loyal Vermont skiing and riding people. We've arrived yet again on the doorstep of another winter season and with that comes another winter weather outlook. Many of you know the drill here. In spite of all the improvements made in seasonal, medium and short range weather forecast, the science remains inexact. Seasonal weather forecasting is especially inexact. It's a fun exercise, but almost guaranteed to have errors in some very noticeable way. This year the exercise is both important and necessary. I love talking about elephants in a room and this year we have a big one and it deserves some significant attention. El Nino was beginning to show it's face late in the last winter season and forecasts then called for some big strengthening. This year, that forecast was accurate and we enter the season facing the strongest recorded El Nino in Mad River Glen's 75-plus year history. Coincidentally, ENSO recorded history runs almost parallel to MRG's existence and recorded snow data at Mt Mansfield's dataset allowing us to make some healthy observations and educated guesses about how this season might play out.
5 Paragraphs on this raging El Nino
I like to call the big El Nino events Super Nino events. I don't think I coined the name, but I do use it and others use it and I only point this out because my definition of a Super Nino might be slightly different than others. It doesn't much matter in a year like this however since we've blown through ever bit of recorded history I could find. We may, by the end of November, record the first month where the critical Nino 3.4 region of the equatorial Pacific Ocean is 3 C above average. El Nino, by definition describes an occurrence where sea surface temperatures in the equatorial regions of the Pacific are above average. La Nino describes the reverse phenomena. There are also variations on that theme with each ENSO event having their own sea surface temperature configurations. I point this out because there is a very peculiar configuration this year which consists of blowout warmth in the eastern equatorial regions of the Pacific while western regions of the Pacific are experiencing more garden variety El Nino conditions. Below is the data as we have it now. Notice we still rank 2nd because this ENSO has yet to peak which it will likely not do until the winter months (hopefully early and I'll explain why) and the November reading which is still ongoing is poised to set all sorts of records. It will be the strongest ENSO and El Nino we've experienced for sure. That is the elephant and it's making quite a bit of noise.
So what does this all mean for our upcoming winter ? A lot actually. The jet stream in the Pacific is just a different animal during any El Nino and considering the strength of this one, the impacts will be accentuated. Big juicy weather systems, much stronger than usual, farther south than usual are a big feature producing flooding rains in California and blizzard-like conditions in the Sierra-Nevada mountains. The strength of the jet in the Pacific also creates big headwinds for both the production and maintenance of arctic cold in central Canada. This often extends into the central United States and northeast and this means mild air is certainly favored over cold and considering the strength of this ENSO event, I would be quite shocked if temperatures didn't conform to this reality. We've already seen these impacts in November with dramatically warmer temperatures over most of the North American continent relative to the more neutral ENSO we saw last year.
Once we put a sunk cost on the mild weather, we can move on to what really matters and that's the stormy/snowy part of this equation. Big juicy southern streamers are the typical result of Super Nino seasons and a few of these have produced some memorable winter storms both across the coastal northeast and interior locations. Interestingly, many of the winters either go one way or the other and we've seen both outcomes in the last decade. The 2015-2016 winter was catastrophic for the interior New England and Vermont as far as snow was concerned. We had a lost month in December which was the blowtorch of all blowtorches (I will talk about this in a subsequent paragraph) and really never recovered in January or February which were closer to normal in terms of temperature but with little to no snow. The one storm that winter resembled the famous Megalopitan Storm of 1982-83 and left Vermont dry. 2023-24 was the mirror image and more closely resembled 1997-98 in that it was both warm and snowy. We saw great interior hits throughout the winter and managed to carry the good fortune well into March culminating in the dream scenario for the Solar Eclipse event on April 8. Two winters, two El Nino's and two entirely different weather personalities in spite of both being quite mild. The illustration below underscores this, but also shows that 2015-2016 was historically unusual. Even the sub-par 1982-83 snow season which featured that aforementioned Megalopitan event most mostly bad because of a slow start before the season managed to make a slow and steady recovery.There's a particular distinction with this El Nino aside from it's strength that was worthy of a paragraph I thought. This animation here shows it very well and illustrates how the El Nino operates in the equatorial regions of the Pacific.
This particular event is very eastern Nino-region based. We've seen others like it but not to this incredible extent. Water temperatures in the eastern equatorial regions of the Pacific are running 5-6 C above normal. To describe it statistically as a "tail event" would not do it justice. It's entirely unheard of and completely new ground as far as how it might impact weather over a winter season. We've had other Super Nino events that had some lesser semblance to this configuration while other big El Nino's featured a more evenly distributed SST configuration. 2015-16 was more evenly distributed while 1997-1998 and 1982-83 more closely resemble the configuration this year. 2023-2024 had a SST configuration similar to this one at the start before the whole event faded. I don't consider it especially wise to draw too many conclusions from this except to say that I am happy we don't look like 2015-2016. It's a pretty small hook to hang my hat on.
There are 4 big conclusions or bullet points I want to make mention of before moving on. 1) It will almost assuredly be warm. It could persist for the entirety of winter, but it will more likely be concentrated around a month or two. 2) We've seen good and bad snow seasons in these Super Nino events as I've highlighted, but almost every one of these years has had the "lost month problem". What does this mean ? When the pattern turns against us it will be especially brutal. We managed to avoid this situations like this in 2009-10 and 2014-15 only because the ENSO event was considerably softer. This one is off the charts and the stronger events seem to be characterized by at least one excessively mild month. Even the fantastic snow season of 2006-07 had a December and early January to forget. 3) We absolutely should be hoping that the El Nino weakens like it did a few years ago. We've produced some really good seasons when El Nino peaks early and then subsides and we can only hope that the excessive equatorial conditions are simply an ENSO that's peaking early. Forecasts support this, but it actually has to happen before we get happy that it's happening. 4) It might not be the most likely outcome, but the risk of having a catastrophically bad winter is considerably higher than it normally would be. A winter featuring big "Miller A" winter storm events is also raised and is certainly the hopium we need, but any winter that is likely turning out this mild also has a higher risk to seriously be lacking in the snowfall category.
PDO Breakdown
5 paragraphs on ENSO hopefully underscores the point that it will be the dominant influence on weather this cold season. Furthermore, it has an influence on the Pacific Decadal Oscillation or PDO which has been negative to varying degrees since December 2019. Refer to the SST animation and one can see the warm horseshoe that extends along the North American west coast. This is what can drive the PDO into positive territory, but also of note is the residual warmth in the central Pacific. The November value might finally break the string of positive indices or it might happen later this winter, but it is likely to break because a Super Nino tends to lead bring that kind of thing about. I tend to thing of this as a positive force on the weather pattern since the jet stream can go extended periods of time without producing a big inland runner type of event. We know the concern about the lack of arctic air so we have to make up for that with a more favorable storm track which appears more likely this year verses prior years.
Snowcover Expansion
Snow cover across the Northern Hemisphere and specifically the expansion of snow cover during the autumn months can provide some insight as to the buildup of potency of arctic cold. I already feel that the arctic cold will be in short supply this year as a result of the strong El Nino yet the October buildup of snow was expanding nicely. We recorded 18.7 millions of square km in October which bested the previous two Octobers. The expansion of ice in the arctic was proceeding in a loose accordance with about the last 10 years of data. More recently however, the expansion of snow has started to drag (so as the sea ice expansion) and as of the current week, is running close to a standard deviation below average. The most current snapshot of data shows us at the third lowest coverage since 1998. In summary, October was encouraging, but the data since then has not been and is yet another variable pointing toward a milder winter.
The Atmospheric Tells
The extreme state of the ENSO renders other atmospheric tells relatively meaningless I think. That said, I went back a few months and tried to examine if we are, regionally, continentally or globally conforming to what we might expect given the Super Nino. In short we are. Temperatures have been mild in any of those three contexts and we are very likely going to blow away land and sea temperature records this winter (globally) thanks to the combination of ENSO conditions and climate change. Super Nino's are capable of adding close to a quarter degree C to global temperatures even when normalizing for longer term trends like climate change. Regionally, interior New England is not at the center of anomalous warmth which is more typically located over the north central part of the North American continent. So far this fall, we've seen a weather pattern that largely supports this conventional configuration. We should expect it to be mild but less mild relative to average than central Saskatchewan.
Summary
This leads us to a nice easy summary. The easier part of the forecast is the temperature part which we should expect to be mild. The warmth will likely be concentrated in a 1-2 month period (hopefully one of those months is right now) and the snow season is likely dependent on what we can do with the months that are not as mild on a relative basis. Hopefully, the ENSO strength will peak early in the season as is the forecast and weaken before the end of the snow season and this often leads to a healthy combination of storms and some cold. As we've seen in previous Super Nino winter seasons, the mild winters can go one of two directions. The better version features a lot of interior hits on storms and often excellent elevation events. The worse version would have a prevailing storm track that shuts New England out of a lot of frozen precipitation. Super Nino's are known for their snow in the southern Appalachian Mountains but the certainty for the mountains of New England is less clear. I would guess that total snow will land below average this year simply because the magnitude of mild air during certain months. That said, we should score some really exciting events that might amount to hardly anything in valley areas. The last two years were made great largely because of an accumulation of smaller events and extended periods with supportive temperatures. The latter will be more challenging this year and we are likely to see lesser smaller events and more bigger events. That's a wrap on this outlook. My wife pointed out to me that AI could write the blog for me if I wanted. I quickly came to the conclusion that would be the most un-MRG thing to do maybe ever. With that in mind, every time you see my latest iteration of a grammatical oversight this winter, rest assured it was a very human person that did that and not Claude Opus 4.8.






No comments:
Post a Comment